Andrei Tarkovsky is a fairly unique proposition as a director in that his films are so consistent; the Russian director only made masterpieces, and Solaris is probably his best known work, although Stalker is also a useful entry point for novices. Casual viewers should not expect bang-for-your-buck with Tarkovsky, but he’s also something of an apex point for intellectual film-making; don’t leave your brain at the door, but turbo-charge it and bring some cushions to sit on if you hope to navigate his unique approach to ‘scuplting in time.’
Adapted from the 1962 book by Polish writer Stanislaw Lem, and it’s probable that you could read the book faster than you can watch the movie, Solaris is a proper Russian sci-fi epic, although for Tarkovsky that doesn’t mean cute robots and fireballs, but at least ninety minutes of people standing in fields reciting poetry to each other before the action leaves earth.
Patience is rewarded, however, and once psychologist Kris Kelvin (Donatas Banionis) gets into space, the reflection gives way to a confrontation with ghostly figures from the past and the future. These are generated by Solaris, a sentient planet below the space station Kelvin inhabits, and the alien contact he experiences is closely related to his own personal experience.
As philosophical as sci-fi gets, Solaris is a meditation, deeply rewarding on a spiritual level. It’s notable that Steven Soderbergh’s truncated remake with George Clooney, well-intentioned as it is, don’t have the same narrative pull; somehow it’s the lengthy gaps between the words that make Tarkovsky’s vision so enduring. Another enduring mystery is that Tarkovsky’s co-writer on his historical epic Andrei Rublev (1966) went on to direct Sylvester Stallone and Kurt Russell in Tango and Cash, but that’s an enigma for another day…
Andrei Rublev surely also deserves a nod. Seem to remember this was a visual intellectual experience more along the lines of 2001 – though without the budget or the music – than Alien.
Yes, I think Solaris gets young sci-go fans looking to upgrade from Kubrick. They get that experience, as long as they are patient.
93 comments as I just looked, and here I am late to the party after having just watched Taken 3. Better than 2. Not as funny as Solaris by any means of course, but the car chase was excellent! 94.
If you watched Taken slowed down to a tenth of its normal speed and watched it with a live organ music soundtrack, reading Russian poetry while lying in a puddle, you’d get the full Tarkovsky experience.
Do you mean lying in a puddle? Or is lying in a paddle a Scottish thing.?
I did, I’ll get it changed. There’s a lot of lying in puddles and Russian poetry.
Mission Accomplished!
I feel a 100’er comment post coming on. Come on Eddie, you can do it!
Mush boy, mush!
~cracks whip
Oh, don’t fade on me now. Drink some Irn brew! Tomorrow is friday. Who cares what happens then. Now, NOW is the moment in history.
Why, what’s happening?
That’s a good question. I wish I had a good answer.
Oh, is that what the occasion is. What has this got to do with Solaris?
Because if we generate 100 comments, we’ll have provided more amusement in one afternoon than Solaris ever did in 50 years….
Well, I’ll pick this up tomorrow. My gravel pizza just arrived….
Back to the movie…
Ahhh, what a good nap. That movie put me right to sleep….
Kept me up till one!
And then you slept so soundly. Probably the best sleep you’ve gotten in decades!
One does not sit down to Solaris for amusement, as you put it. That organ music puts paid to that straight off the bat.
I am properly chastised. I repent in dust and ashes..
Good. Some kind of financial apology is required.
Well, I didn’t want to bring it up. But you still owe me that gold dump truck. I think if you give me a second one, that should square us…
Well I’ve watched the trailer. I thought then that your review must be tongue in cheek, clearly this is a comedy, kind of like a Russian Monty Python movie.
Alex, we are getting the hot takes on Tarkovsky! I do think Fraggle has a point, there is something in the sheer seriousness of Tarkovsky that feels almost like a parody of an arthouse movie.
FFS, that is the worst trailer I’ve ever seen. Crap canned music and worse English dubbing.
Here’s one that plays up the romance angle. Not really what the movie’s about, but the sort of thing Lem complained of when he said Tarkovsky turned his book into “Romeo and Juliet in space.” Still, it’s better than the one in the review.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dgT6dmwYbPc
I have replaced the previous trailer with the one you supplied.
That gets the Alex Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval! No grime on this blog. Next up:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqJ8Teiv6YY
Is this REALLY a good use of my time. Will this film make and simultaneously remake itself while I’m watching? (AO Scott) Will it?
A signature moment in my cinematic development. Nothing stopping you from giving it a watch while you’re waiting for Besson’s Dogman.
Is he getting into the superhero lark too? Big mistake.
I’d better read your review if Pimpkinhewad. I wrote Pumpkinhead but somehow autocorrect thought the first version was more likely.
So I googled Alex Good Pumpkinhead and only your Quiet Place review came up.
I was watching Solaris in the cinema and thought to myself: Oh, Kubrick’s 2001 copied that idea… but only later did I realise it came out after that movie. Can’t remember which bits though, sorry.
That ex-wife character is amazing, their love is so haunted, so sad and moving.
And that ending is so freaky… the twist, the trap, the horror!
Well, I think it’s brilliant. Desert-island disc. Hard to get your hands on a decent English translation of Lem’s book though. I think for some obscure copyright reason the best and most recent is only available as an e-book. The standard English translation is actually translated from a French translation and is apparently very poor.
Didn’t like the Soderbergh movie at all. Just whiffed on everything that made this special. There was a Russian TV adaptation from 1968 that used to be on YouTube but I think it’s been taken down.
Are you finally taking requests around here? You still haven’t done Pumpkinhead . . .
hovere
I’ve got a very old hardback of the original text. If I find it, I’ll mail it to you. Don’t remember it being that awful a translation, but I think it was remaindered from a library in 1980.
Not doing Pumpkinhead, pumpkinhead. Sigh.
I’ve always meant to treat myself to a blu ray boxed set of Tarkovsky’s work, because it’s a must have. Different approach to film-making to anyone else, terrible if you want thrills, but a cold glass of water on a hot day intellectually. But totally agree, one for the desert island. Booky’s trenchant notes on watching it while ironing on Sunday should be included in any future Criterion pressing.
….so, no motorcycle gunfight chases then, I’m gathering.
Have you seen Tango and Cash? One degree of separation from this…
Oh, so this really is right up my alley then. Nice.
(IIRC, didn’t the director of Tango & Cash also direct a version of The Lion in Winter?)
He did!
Well played, that’s a catch!
I dare you to sit through the whole movie. I’ll even let Eddie give you my solid gold award…
You loved it! You even live streamed your joy!
Yes, so much joy.
Comrade….
Pull quote for the poster.
Now you owe me TWO solid gold statues…
That could be a pull quote too ‘ two solid gold statues’ raves Bookstodge.
Don’t forget the rest of the quote “…out of 100″….
‘This is one out of 100 movies I love’ Bookstodge.
Oh my goodness. Worse and worse….
Heh.
I’m actually not averse to slow yet meaningful and philosophical -artistic- movies.
Honest.
I don’t know what comes after a regular dare. I vaguely recollect something to do w dogs.
So I dog dare you…
Nonono, after “Dare” comes “double dare.” Sheesh, man. Get it right. 😀
I don’t make these rules.
Forgive a feeble old man. WHO HAPPENS TO BE THE EMPEROR OF SHADOW ITSELF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yeah. That sets the proper tone 😉
So, where do these dogs I borrowed fit in then? I can only keep them for the next hr…
You’re in luck, dog daring comes after double daring.
That was close! I almost had to have hotdogs for dinner. And I’m fresh out of ketchup!
😉
I Human League Dare you.
The exact nuance and phrase in this ritual is very important.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIsgSQvsRj8
I Dan Dare you.
Ohhhh, you really up the ante with that one! But like I asked Riders, what am I supposed to do with these dogs I borrowed? Expressly for this occasion I might add.
Then this is a perfect example. But serious stuff requires careful handling. Sometimes you need an exploding helicopter…
No, we ALWAYS need an exploding helicopter…
It’s is PREFERABLE to have one.
Well, all I know is that in space no one can hear you scream when the helicopter explodes. So I should think that pretty much settles the matter.
Agreed. Next?
I’ve lost track of whose comment this originally was. So I guess I’ll follow your lead. Onward to paradise.
Comrade….
As a bona fida “I tried”er, all I have to say is how awfully boring the 30min were that I surveyed.
I’d have to give this an 8.0 on the Trotsky Scale and one Stalin out of five on the Hail Comrade metrics.
You have won the Sight and Sound alternative film critic of 2023 with this hot yet radical take on this masterpiece.
When do I get my solid gold statue?
I’m sure solid gold Alex will be along at some point…
I don’t know, it’s 4pm after all. He’s probably sound asleep…
Probably fast asleep watching Tarkovsky movies, they tend to have that effect on those who do not appreciate their subtle nuances…
That seems like the right way to watch his movies…
It’s like an induced coma. Solaris is one of the early, funny ones.
I’m still waiting for your live reaction video: Booky First Time Watching Solaris!
Just add a pix of someone with their eyes and mouth as open as they can go. With fake blood geysering out of my head. That should get my reaction across pretty good 😉
Haha! Not sure why I’m laughing, as that’s a pretty terrifying image. Part Scanners, part Clockwork Orange!
It says something for the level of discourse that I paid so little attention to this image, but now that you mention it…
And 100% Bookstodge!
😮
Just watched Alex’s substitute trailer; that organ music! Back in the days of wobbly VHS sound, it used to sound very much like a Monty Python sketch. It seems the internet demands a livestream of you watching this film.
The internet demands a lot of things. Like instagram claiming they need a phone number AND a picture of “me” holding some flipping code. So my youtube debut is probably right around the corner, hahahahaha….
Dude, that sounds like you’ve been kidnapped, did they make you hold a newspaper under your chin and look into the camera?
They would have liked me too. I couldn’t believe that was what people would do to join some online place. ….
Are they feeding you? How tightly are you guarded? Nod twice for yes, once for no.
blink
blink
blinkblinkblinkblink (which means “give me pizza!!!!!”)
With gravel? Once for yes, two for no, three for not sure.
blink
blinkblinkblinkblink
blink
kerblink
Ok, so two slices of gravel glued to a plate, and for desert?
blink
blipblipblip
With or without garnish?
Hey, isn’t it like midnight there? Shouldn’t you be in bed, asleep?
Waaaaaaait a second, you’re one of the kidnappers aren’t you? I knew I smelled space haggis….
They are under my auspices, yes.
Your washing machine, the cycles, the speed please…?
Oh. My. Goodness.
I never saw this coming!
Who could?
PSYCHIC GRANDMA SAW THIS COMING FROM A MILE AWAY!
Sadly, I am not Psychic Grandma…
And yet your prediction is correct, so what does that mean?
That forces beyond our control control our every move, thought and deed and we are truly helpless meat puppets?
OR….
that if the Carebears had watched this movie, they could have solved everyone’s problem in about 30minutes…
What problem would that be?
That’s there is not enough Care Bears movies…
Now you’re just filibustering.
Wut?!
I am not! I care deeply, very deeply, about the Care Bears.
We’re artificially inflating figures to create a veneer of social media success.
OR….
we’re just having fun. Your choice.
The latter.
Well, it is now 0530. Tough to have fun at that time in the morning imo…
True.
I’d buy that for a dollar!
Fifty cents for me but I’m cheap!
I’ll chip in for you.
don’t trust Eddie for a plugged nickel. He stiffed me a gold dump truck….
That gold dump truck is always just over the hill . . .
It really is. Just like a leprechaun’s pot of gold…