You are under arrest from the moment Transit begins; this critic literally had to restart Christian Petzold’s original film to get his head round the film’s uniqueness. This is an adaptation of a novel by Anna Seghers published back in 1944, but the details are not in keeping with the book’s period; the sight and sound of modern ambulances and police vehicles interrupt the action, and the clothes seem deliberately chosen to not evoke any specific era.
In this German/French co-production, set in a parallel universe, the dialogue and the situations are set out in much more detail, and they relate as much to 2018 as 1944. The building of walls and the re-enforcing of borders has led to an inevitable conclusion; almost everyone caught up in this story is a refugee of some kind. Georg (Franz Rogowski) leaves Paris for Marseilles carrying the writings of a recently deceased author and a letter from the author’s wife; it allows him to pass himself off as the writer, and potentially access to a precious opportunity to flee the fascist occupation of his country and head to Mexico.
Georg is in transit, even if he’s temporarily stuck in the port while he works through various official channels. But his journey takes a diversion when he attempts to help a sick child, and becomes involved with the doctor who helps him, and a lover Marie (Paula Beer), who was previously married to the writer he’s impersonating. The situation is oppressive; there are, to paraphrase a line from Titanic, ‘too many people and not enough boats’; Georg must consider who will make it out of Marseilles alive, and what role he will play in the escape.
Transit is a powerful film that blazes a trail that puts most film-makers to shame. There’s a great throwaway line about a zombie movie where the undead congregate on a shopping mall; even the dead, one character comments, seem to have run out of ideas. Petzold’s distain for genre tropes is invigorating; he brings a classic text to life in a way that never puts it behind glass to admire. Instead he updates the sentiment in a way that focuses on the timeless personal suffering of the dispossessed; Transit captures where the political directions of 2019 were leading to, before the plague speeded up the pace of the unfolding car-crash of fascism.
Glad to hear it’s readily available. I need to balance out every Cocaine Bear with something deeper, insightful and more thoughtful. On the basis of your review I checked the director out. Some very interesting movies.
Yup, looked it up on the itvx app. Carry on Emmanuelle as well, as a contrast.
Ideal double bill.
Transit is free to watch on itvX in the UK.
I’d argue that Christian Petzold is the most consistently good director working in Germany and in Paula Beer and Franz Rogowski in this film he has two of the best younger actors in Europe to work with.
I noticed it was on itvX, is that with adverts? Adverts do my scone in…
Totally agree. A great director and two terrific players…can’t believe this is on itvX!
Yes, the free stream is with (at the moment minimal) ads. You can do a free trial of the premium service without ads – which then requires a subscription for long-term ad-free viewing, just like All4.
Great to have a film like this out there, within reach of casual viewers. It deserves to be widely seen.
Searching for better word than brilliant for your critique of this fascinating film…luminescent, masterly? Film artfully delves into numerous areas, existence, loss, trauma, distortion, risk… while there’s been a rash of WW2 Nazi’esque films on Netflix and elsewhere, more are needed to expose the white, gory underbelly of fascism. Well done!
This is history from a text by someone who lived through it. By smirring the time period, they somehow emphasizes how close past times are, and how easily they could break out again. We are sitting on the brink of fresh catastrophe and revisiting old war movies isn’t enough. We need to talk about now…o my stars, thanks for the compliment. This film sticks with you.
Applaud you for going to the effort of finding better words to describe a review. Hats off!
Yes please! I hope this comes to my local. This looks worth getting dressed and leaving the house for…..
This is a very classy and thoughtful film. Ideal for a double bill with Cocaine Bear. Get your glad rags on!
So instead of turning around and facing their problems, and even possibly solving them, everybody runs away. And we’re supposed to think that is good? It’s that thought process that has contributed greatly to the mess the world is in now.
Having a hard time figuring out what this movie is about from your description. So a maybe.
Sigh. What’s your problem, Bunty? Literate readers like fraggle not having any probs…
There’s a guy pretending to be a writer played by Liam Neeson and he has to kill someone on a train to save his daughter and get some papers from Rick if he wants to make it out of Casablanca but then there’s a zombie outbreak in a mall and the Titanic sinks and we never find out if he makes it to the border of Mexico?
That’s it in a nutshell, what’s the problem?
Is the hero a transman or a transwoman?
Do we have to provide a label?
So we should just say . . . Trans-it?
I checked and he is a transformer ie robot in disguise.
I re-read my review and it is a perfect review. People come up to me with tears in their eyes and say, Sir, and then tell me how perfect it is.
I thought the write-up suggested the movie had a bit of Michael Bay about it. Were they talking about this sort of perfection?
No more Travolta, Die Hart killed my enthusiasm. Quite keen on Bay these days, keep meaning to buy Ambulance. Now there is a film that simultaneously makes and remakes cinema itself while you are watching it…
I might have misunderstood the review.
That looks really good, if it streams sometime I’ll see it. Yep!
Is the correct answer. Ebeneezer seems to be struggling with the bigger words…
Why id Alex Ebeneezer all of a sudden?
is not id before you start.
He’s so Good, he’s Ebeneezer Good!
Hmm. If you say so. I have no idea what you’re on about.
Classic song by The Shamen?
Not heard of them or it sorry.
Thanks for that. I checked it out, it’s all a bit manic for me and I couldn’t get all the words. Some one called Dale commented underneath “. It’s basically a mini-course in early 90s Britain counter-culture, conservative politics, 90s music, cockney rhyming slang, and even little bit of classic English literature.” So I looked up the lyrics, and decided that Dale was a knob.
Glad I could take you on this journey! Anyway, Alex’s name is Good, and he seems like a real sound geezer, so my conclusion is that he’s Ebenezer Good.
Plenty of knobs out there.
OK I consider myself fully informed now.
Great, glad we had this talk. Lunch?
Skipping it today, finishing work at 2pm then off to ASDA for the weekly extorsion.
There’s some risotto in the fridge if you are peckish. Could you get some ice poles and cat litter? Thanks.
Failed on that sorry. Got Dreamies and Creamy Dreamy if that’s any good.
Don’t your cats ‘go’ outside?
No. House cats only. No Cocaine Bear dramas.
But..but..but you live on a farm!! Plenty of land for them to play out in. Even my 2 go out, they love being out in the sun and being all catty. Winnie would go insane if she couldn’t go out when she wanted.
Would love for them to get out, but we have a 40mph road yards from out door. Trained house cats who love to frolic in the sun; fifty feet or corridor keeps them running around happily enough.
That’s not too bad then.
They love it!