Forty years after it was shot, this adaptation of a sci-fi novel by Doris Lessing finally feels like it’s bang up to date. Originally written in 1974, Lessing’s book is a familiar brand of dystopian future; most machines have stopped functioning, society has broken down, feral children and gangs roam the streets, the few who remain in the cities are left to sit terrified in their tower-blocks, waiting for the barbarians to come and eat their pets. So far, so 2020, but Lessing is not a writer concerned with simple take-away meanings, and there’s much more to her vision than just disaffection.
Julie Christie plays D, presumably short for Doris, a woman who lives alone in her flat, but seems to be able to visit the past through a strange membranous wall; Lessing is interested in dreams, and how they relate to reality. We see D travel back to Victorian times, and witness the behaviours of a family; this feels very similar to 1974’s Jacques Rivette film Celine and Julie Go Boating in which a haunted house provides similar insights for the protagonists. Meanwhile, D invites a surrogate into her house, a girl named Emily (Leonie Mellinger). Emily is initially repulsed, then seduced by Gerald, who organises street-gangs of homeless Norwich children into teams, but D is suspicious of Gerald, and a brooding conflict develops between the women and the potential leader.
The sci-fi trappings of Memoirs of a Survivor are deliberately obscure; an opening caption ‘When Things Stopped’ doesn’t reveal much about what’s gone wrong with the world, but it’s clear that Lessing blames things on the patriarchy; newspaper hoardings offer bland statements like ‘Talks Continue’ while the papers themselves offer such generic phrases as “Flashpoint’ interspersed with the topless girl models which were ubiquitous in UK culture at the time. But there is no relief in the past; the Victorian father that D imagines, played by Nigel Hawthorne, seems dissatisfied with his wife and drawn towards abusing his own daughter; such motives are implied rather than seen, but it’s clear that Lessing sees a firm connection between the sins of the fathers and the current decay.
Memoirs of a Survivor brings back a number of members of the team who made classic State-of-the-nation address O Lucky Man, editor David Gladwell directs and Michael Medwin produces, while veteran Kerry Lee Crabbe co-wrote the script. Walter Lassally (Before Midnight) handles the lensing in a memorably spare way. Audiences and critics were utterly nonplussed by this film in 1981, but viewed from 2020, it’s a route-one attack on the patriarchy, and demonstrates an identifiable political and feminist slant that’s highly persuasive. Hard to see for 40 years, it’s a humble £2.50 to stream from the BFI right now, and worth a look for those seems to swap our current lockdown dystopia for a more literary, but no less chilling state of urban decay.
https://player.bfi.org.uk/rentals/film/watch-memoirs-of-a-survivor-1981-online
I love Christie. But this is a nope.
🤣🤣🤣👍
What are you laughing at! Stop it! Behave!
Never.
A yellow card for dissent.
Pfft.
You’re only making it worse for yourself.
Impossible.
Yup.
Exactly! Glad you agree!
Sigh
Fair enough, it’s not a lot of laughs…
Skipped this at the time but it may be a lot more appropriate now.
I find it kind of hypnotic in places, and they find something cinematic to match the prose style. But the narrative is a challenge….
Looks pretty decent so might give it a watch sometime.
It’s very arty, but discerning audiences like yourself could do worse…
Can you get the BFI channel on a monthly premium on Amazon? I might get that for a while.
They had a month free preview not long ago, worth clicking it to find out…lots of good stuff, even worth paying for!
Nope. Sick of dystopia now.
Sigh…how can you be sick of dystopia?
Doom and gloom overload.
Boo! Lots to look forward to in 2021. Chevy Chase season on it’s way!
Kill me now.
Steven Seagull?
Pfft!
I’d watch a movie where Steven kills the Chevster!
Yes, then Van Damme kills Seagull and Michael Caine tops Van Damme off and wins the day!
Thanks for these insights into the writings of Doris Lessing.
Oh, that sounds like my dream movie!
I’ve liked about half of the Van Damme movies I’ve seen, so I guess that is pretty good considering my watching habits 🙂
Considering your watching habits, I’m surprised you haven’t seen them all…
You mean my one movie a month habit? 😀
Seems a shame to limit yourself to van damme…
That’s why God invented Keanu Reeves 😉
Certainly seems like a heavenly creation.
John Wick agrees 🙂
We have a winner…
I know you’re not an action movie kind of guy, but have you seen Man of Tai Chi with Tiger Chen as the lead character? Reeves plays the badguy in that one and I enjoyed the story. Just wondering what you thought of it, if you’d seen it.
I liked it, thought it was a sleek movie, and will watch Reeves in just about anything. And I am more of an action guy than you can imagine. They call me Action Jackson.
Do you pronounce Jackson differently with a scottish accent? Like, Jocksahn? Or Jaxanne?
Your international readers want to know!
It should rhyme exactly with Jackson.
That’s what I thought. Jocksanne. Glad we could clear that up.
Van Damme is the Chevy Chase of Martial Art movies.
I liked Blood Sport though! And Street Fighter? Yeah!
And this is the level of discussion of Doris Lessing’s work my blog seems to attract….
Are you being a snob? Videogamers deserve movies too you know….
Should I go on comments sections for Tron Legacy and try and get discussions going about Doris Lessing? The Tron video game was so rubbish I sold it, you dodn’t get that in the Disney movies…
I say go for it. Good luck with discussing Lessing on Legacy though 😉
I never played any of the Tron games, just watched the totally and completely awesome movies.
So who is the video game snob, then! At least I play the games…
Whoaa there pardner, are you implying that I’m a videogame snob? That playing videogames is a complete waste of a person’s time and that it is akin to watching movies all day? 🙂 Say it ain’t so, Ol’10!
Actually, I am a huge videogame snob. I played a lot in highschool and college but after that, I took up reading and dropped videogames. Even now, while I’d like to play the New Doom games, there is just no way that is going to happen.
Planning on reviewing a few classic games in 2021, no snob me! Just don’t have the time right now, and I’m a story guy rather than open world…
The idea of an “open world” for a videogame is anathema to me. Give me a story with checkpoints along the way. Probably comes from me being such a Quest oriented guy even in my reading 😀
What falls under the “classic games” banner for you? A time frame or some other indicator?
I find open world games like Skyrim or Red Dead to be very tiresome; I don’t want to live in a community, just have an adventure. I found the Naughty Dog games, Uncharted, Last of Us, very cinematic, and worth reviewing….
Oh, you’re a Last of Us fan? Were you one of those who hated the sequel because of X reasons? I don’t actually know a thing about that franchise, but I sure did see a lot of spillover from fans about it…
Was warned off the sequel, but played the first one through twice. Gripping game, like living through a movie, hard to explain, but a great narrative…
Well, glad to hear you avoided the rage/depression inducing sequel. What console did you play the original on?
A wind up gramophone, I think. Or a PS3, which still gets used for blu rays…
Huh, amazing what modern gramophones can do. Things just haven’t been the same since young Edison played around…
What’s your game of choice? Dombey and Son on the Sega?
Personally, I liked the cutting 32bit graphics of Medium Dorrit, Mind Flayer on the original Play Station.
Did you ever make it to the top of Bleak House? Not easy set to crushing…
I only play my Dickens Games on easy. Otherwise the cut scenes take about 5hrs each. And with 52 of them (one for each week), it takes a bleeding year to finish the game.
I played Grant Theft Auto; Dickensian on crushingly hard, and it was brutal. There’s a secret level where you enter a code to witness a lecture on railway aqueducts.
Dude, you are Hard Core! Major kudo props thingies to you…
That’s how I roll…
R4sPekt!
*fingers pointing everywhere*
Raise the roof dancing… and what a feeling it is, when you’re dancing on the ceiling…
Hey, in my Mental Palace, it’s practically Escherland!
Could you use it as a storage facility?
Sorry, that’s what my imaginary 2 car garage is for. Mental Palace is for fun stuff only! Like knitting and peeling potatoes….
I have an imaginary pagoda in my back garden, more of an imaginary treehouse really.
Is your back garden imaginary too? Those are the easiest to grow things in and to weed…
Couldn’t tell you, imaginary gardener organised the whole thing, you’d need to ask him.
Call me a modern snob, but I don’t talk to the imaginary Help. It’s really asking too much of me….
Obviously I don’t do the talking myself, I’m not a savage…
Oh, thank goodness for that! I was beginning to wonder if I’d wandered into the wrong blog club here. Only the snobbiest and most elite for me, thank you very much.
I thought you knew this club was imaginary…
All the best clubs are!
Reality is so gauche…
And a happy new year to you !
Wow, you stayed up for it? Good job.
I’m going to bed at 10pm….
That was three hours ago! It’s a time paradox!
Not if you’re a Time Lord, like me. I’m the REAL Dr. Who.
Dr Lord Bookstooge, at your service.
The real Dr Who does not consider himself to be in service to anyone, so it’s clearly a ruse.
wut?
Wut what?
wut wut wut wut wut?
Maybe if they had recipes for pets, THEN I’d watch it. I get my fill of feminist agenda in real life, thank you. So a movie needs a lot more than that to draw me in. Pet recipes would do it for sure.
I’d make some other clever and smart alecky remarks, but it is too early. My brain just isn’t firing on all cylinders yet.
Where do you get your fill of feminist agenda? I’d by lying if I said that receptors for pets were the main thrust of this story, but it is one element…
Every time I turn on the radio, read a blog I don’t normally follow, etc. I was going to say “talk with someone in the store”, but that hasn’t happened in over a year due to covid. One good thing about a pandemic, people are much more likely to leave me alone in real life.
#sohappy
I understand. This movie missed out on a golden opportunity though. It could have explored the nuanced differences in taste between ketchup, mustard, relish and soy sauce.
I’ll dig up Doris Kessong and see if a Menoirs of a Survivor Cookbook could be a go-er
I’m telling you, a pet cookbook would sell like hotcakes!
It might sell like hot cats
Dang! Way to go there 😉
(I’m just jealous that I didn’t think of it first!)
Although now that the dust has settled, I’m not sure what kind of market there is for warm felines.
Well, not much of one here in America. People treat their pets like kids! *grrrrrr*
So we just need to find a country that treats pets as portable food and we can make a killing with the cookbook…
I take it that you don’t have any pets, like Queen Gedron’s giant spider in Red Sonja?
Nope. Our condo association is a pet free one. No rabid skunks running around our condos!
A tamagotchi ?
I think Mrs B had one back when it was the craze. I don’t know if you can still even buy them, can you? Anyway, I can’t see frying up tamagotchi’s with ketchup…
A giant spider like Queen Gedron? Mrs B?
Oh yeah, she rode it around like a horse every day. That’s actually how she caught me. Ran me down with her giant spider and then married me using her Queen Powers….
Knew I was into something…
See, you are winkling out our every secret! Before you know it, I’ll be confessing my crimes as a fashionista bank robber.
Ooops!
Do go on…nice clear voice for the tape please…
Then there was that time I disabled the guard with my pinstriped 4 piece suit. I was pretty proud of that. Getting your 4piece suit off while keeping your ski mask on takes an incredible amount of skill and talent.
Did you Bookstooge his pants, or your own?
Both. It was a new record for me and when I started, I was pretty nervous, you know? But once I’d bookstooged my own pants and my 4piece suit was all on the guard, I realized, hey, I can do this! The nervousness disappeared and voila, I totally double bookstooged his pants too.
Quite a confession. Just look for the red dot. Just raise your hands and we’ll have you in the stripey hole in no time.
Excellent! Now I don’t have to go to work tomorrow.
What a relief. I was not looking forward to the job planned for us.
Petty larceny is such a grind. I work both sides in a cash for crypto deal. How’s you fancy we take a crack at larceny of a more…grand variety?
I’m totally up for that. 2021 is the year for New Things, right? So let’s try something new.
I figure could knock off a royal mint somewhere…
Stealing confectionary from the Queen? Daring?
As long as it’s yummy, I’m good with that.
I’ll have my people contact yours. Which it to say my lawyers will negotiate with your parole officers. Get yer trousers on, yer nicked!
Well, once I get Psychic Grandma as my lawyer, I’m scot (ha!) free!
I’d watch that, would need to include horseradish and tartare sauce too though as a subplot.
I’ll go as far as the tartar sauce, but horseradish? I’m gonna have to pass on that.
Nope
Pfffffftttt!
Blerk!
snort!
Sigh
You win. I can’t think of any 3letter noise words….
Trained by the best…you came close! But no cigar…
Try Gah! I’ve been holding that in reserve but I’m feeling magnanimous.
I’ll stick in that my arsenal of noise words. Thanks.
Blerk!
Gah!
Well done.
Blerk
You’re getting the hang of it.
It’s so yummy with roast beef though.
Nope
‘Tis.
Snot.
Sigh.
Hm. Maybe? Not jumping to the top of my playlist but I’ll keep it in mind.
Tough crowd….this is my second review of this film, and while I get that it’s quite arty, I think more people would like this if they gave it a try. Like Christie, like Lessing, like O lucky Man, and always keen to get advice about navigating dystopias….