My Man Godfrey 1938 ****

A change of pace is required, perhaps; 1936’s My Man Godfrey is certainly something out of the ordinary, a screwball comedy, a massive hit at the time, but making all kinds of assumptions which seem fantastically odd by modern standards. This is a comedy, but also a sharp social satire, and there’s a sense of responsibility in Gregory La Cava’s fizzy concoction that’s highly unusual.

After some very creative titles, the film opens briskly with a scavenger hunt, during which a couple of rich broads are searching the city dump for a ‘forgotten man’. As an into, this catches today’s viewer cold; it’s possible that one might imagine what a scavenger hunt is, but what kind of amusement would involve finding tramps? A self-centred one, the film reveals, since the two women Cordelia and Irene Bullock (Gail Patrick and Paulette Goddard) pick something of a cracker in Godfrey (William Powell), who initially rejects their request, only to succumb to curiosity about what a scavenger party is. Once Godfrey sees the potential humiliation, he denounces the entire well-to-do party as ‘nitwits’ and storms out, but not before Irene has twigged that he might be not only a good butler for her madcap family, but also a potential husband for herself.

There’s some elements of Bondu Saved from Drowning here, as a tramp shows frivolous richies how to behave, but there’s also a biting disdain for the mannered lifestyle of the wealthy; if you thought the Kardashians are a laughing stock, then the Bullocks are the 1930’s equivalent, brainless, self-centred and celebrating their own idiocy for our entertainment without a trace of self-awareness that the joke is on them. Idiot artist Carlo, played by the great Mischa Auer, is a particular delight, and the scene in which he leaps around the parlour pretending to be a monkey foreshadows a similar scene in 2018’s The Square.

It wouldn’t be until American Hustle that a film would win Oscar nominations in every major category other than Best Picture; today’s prejudice against comedies is nothing new. But My Man Godfrey’s class critique stings; Godfrey is clearly convinced that his masters are utter twits, and acts on it, so La Cava’s film has more social relevance that a dozen ‘prestige’ picture. While a few scenes drag, there’s also some absolutely crackling dialogue and delivery to savour here, not least because the two stars had got divorced several years before the film was made.


Leave a Reply