Q & A 1990 ****

Sidney Lumet’s feel for New York veracity led to blistering cinema including Serpico and Dog Day Afternoon; the best of his later work, including Before The Devil Knows Your Dead, has a more static feel but is no less savvy. 1990’s Q & A was not popular at the time, but it’s a meaty, substantial film that deals with genuine issues.

Fresh-faced assistant DA Al Reilly (Timothy Hutton) has his first case to deal with, and dirty cop Mike Brennan (Nick Nolte) has lots to hide. A self-defence shooting is revealed as a cold-blooded execution in the opening scene, and Reilly’s unravelling of the truth is the main thrust of the story. A second thread, involving Reilly’s romantic feelings towards to wife of drag baron Bobby Tex (Armand Assante) feels a bit more contrived, but the way Lumet details corruption, from a book by Supreme Court judge Edwin Torres (Carlito’s Way), is unflinching and absorbing for every minute of the 132 here.


Leave a Reply
  1. Funnily enough, I rewatched Family Business in 2018 and was far more interested in it now than then. Find Me Guilty also a great neglected Lumet!

  2. Remember enjoying this at the time even though it made a fleeting visit to the cinema. Family business is worth a second look because that was an epic misfire at the time – not a recommendation just a thought.

Leave a Reply